I'm having a hard time
trying to find you in my memories.
Your face and name are the same
but everything else was just made up for me.

Now I know I never knew you.
So how could I ever have loved you?
That will always be a mystery

I'm dealing with holes in my chest.
'Cause every heartache just gets pushed out instead.
It's always painful to change.
But all of the time we shared now feels so strange.

Now I know I never knew you.
So how could I ever have loved you?
That will always be a mystery

Don't you know you never knew me
So how could you ever have loved me?
I will always be a mystery